Once a family decides a parent needs help at home, the next question comes fast: do we go through an agency, or hire someone ourselves? A private caregiver found through a friend or an online listing often looks cheaper per hour. An agency often looks simpler. Both can work, but the trade-offs aren’t always obvious until something goes wrong.
This guide compares hiring through a home care agency with hiring a private (independent) caregiver: cost, screening, backup coverage, taxes, liability and day-to-day management. It’s written for families in California, where state law adds a few specific rules.
What’s the difference between an agency caregiver and a private caregiver?
An agency caregiver is employed by a home care company. The agency recruits, screens, trains, schedules, pays and supervises the caregiver, and sends a replacement when the regular caregiver is out. You pay the agency.
A private caregiver, also called an independent caregiver, private-duty caregiver or independent provider, works for your family directly. You find them, check their background, set the schedule, pay them, and handle everything if they’re sick, quit, or something goes wrong.
| Through an agency | Private caregiver | |
|---|---|---|
| Who finds the caregiver | The agency | Your family |
| Background checks | Done by the agency | Up to you |
| Training and supervision | Provided by the agency | Up to you |
| Backup when the caregiver is out | The agency sends someone | Your family covers or goes without |
| Payroll taxes and insurance | Handled by the agency | Often your responsibility as the employer |
| Hourly cost | Usually higher | Usually lower |
| Your time spent managing | Less | More |
What are the four types of caregivers?
People group caregivers in different ways, but for families hiring help, four types come up most often:
- Family caregivers: spouses, adult children and other relatives, usually unpaid.
- Agency caregivers: employed and supervised by a home care company.
- Private or independent caregivers: hired directly by the family.
- Skilled medical providers: nurses and therapists, usually from a home health agency, who provide medical care ordered by a doctor.
Most families end up with a mix, such as a family caregiver plus paid help for some hours, or home health visits alongside non-medical home care.
The pros and cons of hiring through an agency
Advantages of a home care agency
- Screening is done for you. In California, Home Care Organizations must be licensed by the state, and the same law created a public registry of background-checked home care aides (CDSS).
- Backup coverage. If the caregiver is sick or on vacation, the agency sends someone else.
- Training and supervision. The agency trains caregivers and checks on the quality of care.
- No employer paperwork. The agency handles payroll, taxes and insurance.
- Room to grow. It’s easier to go from a few hours to 24/7 care when an agency has a team.
Disadvantages of a home care agency
- Higher hourly cost, because the rate covers screening, training, insurance, scheduling and backup.
- Less control over who comes, especially with agencies that rotate caregivers often.
- Minimum shift lengths at some agencies.
The pros and cons of hiring a private caregiver
Advantages of hiring a private caregiver
- Often a lower hourly rate.
- You choose the person and work out the routine directly with them.
- A close one-on-one relationship when the match is right.
Disadvantages of hiring a private caregiver
- You’re responsible for screening. Background checks, references and verifying experience are up to you.
- No backup. When the caregiver is sick, quits or takes a vacation, care stops unless the family steps in.
- You may be an employer, with payroll tax and paperwork obligations (more below).
- Liability. If the caregiver is injured in your parent’s home, or something goes missing or goes wrong, there may be no insurance or company to turn to.
- Management falls on the family: schedules, time off, problems and difficult conversations.
Want the flexibility of one-on-one care without becoming an employer?
What is one disadvantage of employing an independent provider?
The biggest disadvantage for most families is having no backup. With one private caregiver, care depends on one person’s health, schedule and plans. If they’re sick on a Monday morning or leave suddenly, there’s no one to call, and a parent who can’t be left alone needs someone right away. The second big disadvantage is the employer responsibility that comes with paying someone directly.
Taxes: when a private caregiver is your household employee
The IRS includes caretakers and health aides in its list of household workers. If you hire a caregiver directly and control what work is done and how, they may be your household employee, and you may owe employment taxes (IRS Publication 926).
- For 2026, Social Security and Medicare taxes apply to a household worker you pay $3,000 or more in cash wages during the year (IRS Publication 926).
- Federal unemployment tax can also apply, based on how much you pay household workers each quarter.
- California has its own household employer rules through the Employment Development Department (EDD), including state payroll taxes and reporting.
By contrast, the IRS explains that if an agency provides the worker and controls what work is done and how it’s done, the worker isn’t your employee (IRS Publication 926). This is one of the most overlooked differences between the two options. Talk with a tax professional about your situation, since Premier Comfort Care doesn’t give tax advice.
How much do private caregivers charge per hour?
Rates for private caregivers vary widely depending on experience, the care needed, location and schedule, and there’s no single going rate. When you compare a private rate with an agency rate, add the costs that come with being an employer: payroll taxes, workers’ compensation or liability coverage, background checks, and the cost of covering shifts when the caregiver is out. The gap is often smaller than it looks.
Do private caregivers get paid more?
Not necessarily. A private caregiver may keep more of each hour’s pay because there’s no agency in between, but they also usually go without what an employer provides, such as paid training, workers’ compensation coverage, steady scheduling and someone to cover their shifts. Some caregivers prefer the stability of agency work for those reasons.
What are caregivers not allowed to do?
Whether you hire privately or through an agency, non-medical caregivers help with daily life, not medical care. They typically don’t provide skilled nursing tasks such as wound care, injections or managing IV lines, which need a licensed nurse. Agencies set clear policies on what their caregivers can and can’t do. With a private caregiver, it’s up to the family to set those boundaries and make sure the caregiver isn’t asked to do tasks they’re not qualified for.
Watch: how families stay involved with agency care
If you hire privately: protect your family
If a private caregiver is the right choice for you, take these steps:
- Ask whether they’re listed on California’s Home Care Aide Registry, which lists aides who have been background checked.
- Check references, as the NIA recommends before hiring any person or company (NIA).
- Put the job in writing: duties, hours, pay, time off and what happens if either side wants to end the arrangement.
- Talk with a tax professional about household employer obligations.
- Check whether your homeowner’s insurance covers a worker injured in the home, or get coverage.
- Keep valuables and financial documents secured, and watch bank statements.
- Line up a backup plan for days the caregiver can’t come.
Which is right for your family?
There’s no wrong answer, only the one that fits your parent’s needs, your family’s time and how much risk you’re comfortable carrying. Many families start one way and change as needs grow.
A private caregiver can work well when your parent’s needs are light and predictable, a family member lives nearby to cover gaps, and you’re comfortable handling payroll and supervision.
An agency is usually the better fit when your parent can’t safely be left alone, when care needs are growing, when the family lives far away or works full time, or when you simply don’t want to be an employer. Before you hire, use our list of questions to ask a home care agency to compare your options. And if you’re managing care from out of town, our guide to long-distance caregiving covers how to stay involved from afar.
How Premier Comfort Care helps
Premier Comfort Care provides non-medical home care in Sacramento, Folsom, Roseville, Granite Bay, El Dorado Hills, Elk Grove, Rocklin, Citrus Heights and nearby communities. We aim to give families the best of both: the consistency of a familiar caregiver, with an agency’s screening, training and backup behind them. Our caregiver retention is 65%, five times higher than the industry average.
Care can start with 1–2 hour microvisits and grow to 24/7 care, including weekends and holidays. Families follow along through our family portal, unused care credits are fully refundable, and when you call, you’ll talk directly with our owner, Mariam.
Weighing your options? Talk it through with Mariam.
Sources: IRS Publication 926, Household Employer’s Tax Guide; CDSS, Home Care Services Consumer Protection Act; CDSS, Home Care Aide Registry; National Institute on Aging, Services for older adults living at home.






